Skip to content
Make a Payment

Our Insurance Companies

Insurance Companies

Wagner Insurance Agency represents the following insurance companies

Click on a company to view contact information.

Claims

800-346-0346

website

Payments

800-346-0346

website

More info about Auto Owners

Claims

800-445-3030

website

Payments

800-425-1100

website

More info about Grange Insurance

Claims

800-225-2467

website

Payments

800-824-7317

website

More info about Liberty Mutual

Claims

800-776-4737

website

Payments

888-671-4405

website

More info about Progressive

Claims

800-332-3226

website

Payments

800-332-3226

website

More info about Safeco

Claims

website

Payments

website

More info about United States Liability Insurance Group

Claims

800-362-0426

website

Payments

800-362-0426

website

More info about Western Reserve Group

Claims

800-243-0210

website

Payments

800-243-0210

website

More info about Westfield Insurance

Claims

888-641-5224

website

Payments

888-641-5224

website

More info about Anthem

Claims

800-448-6262

Payments

800-448-6262

More info about Humana
More info about Medical Mutual of Ohio

Claims

888-842-4571

Payments

888-842-4571

More info about UnitedHealthcare